Welcome to Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Should New York Apologize for Slavery?

Last post 07-30-2007, 12:46 AM by Anonymous. 31 replies.
Page 1 of 3 (32 items)   1 2 3 Next >
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  02-25-2007, 7:39 AM 144

    Should New York Apologize for Slavery?

    Since the Dutch colonial period,  New York City's early economy was slave-based (starting in 1626).  In fact, New Amsterdam could not have survived (or feed its struggling population) without slave labor.  Even after New York's slaves were freed in 1827, the City's economy relied heavily on the trans-Atlantic trade with slave states (cotton, etc.), which was the foundation of our great prosperity as a world financial capital.  Wall Street bankrolled the maintenance and expansion of slavery.  For those of you who haven't checked it out, there is a great exhibit at the New York Historical Society.

    The Virginia legislature just passed a resolution taking responsibility for slavery and the aftermath of this "peculiar institution" in the home of Thomas Jefferson, George Washington, and other Founding Fathers.  On a side note, it's interesting that Pre
    sident Jefferson -- the great champion of liberty and author of the Declaration of Independence -- provided military and economic assistance to help put down the first successful slave revolt (in the French colony of Haiti).  When a fellow Virginian landowner and protégé, Edward Coles, proposed to free his own slaves, Jefferson responded: ''We have the wolf by the ear, and we can neither hold him, nor safely let him go.''  So much for 'self-evident' truths.
     
    Should the New York City Council introduce a similar resolution?
     
    --- 
    Published: Feb. 25, 2007 at 8:48 AM
    Virginia apologizes for slavery
    RICHMOND, Va., Feb. 25 (UPI) -- The Virginia General Assembly has unanimously expressed "profound regret" for Virginia's role in slavery.

    Sponsors of the symbolic resolution believe Virginia is the first state to pass such a measure, WTTG-TV, Washington, reported. The Missouri Legislature is considering a similar apology.

    The House approved the resolution 96-0 and it passed the 40-member Senate unanimously as well Saturday, the Fox network affiliate reported.

    Richmond is the former Confederate Capitol and was a hub of the slave-trade.

    The resolution says slavery "ranks as the most horrendous of all depredations of human rights and violations of our founding ideals in our nation's history, and the abolition of slavery was followed by systematic discrimination, enforced segregation, and other insidious institutions and practices toward Americans of African descent that were rooted in racism, racial bias, and racial misunderstanding."

    The resolution also apologizes for "the exploitation of Native Americans."


    The world is a skirt I want to lift up.
    -Hanif Kureishi, author (1954- )
  •  02-25-2007, 10:45 AM 148 in reply to 144

    Re: Should New York Apologize for Slavery?

    This would be a positive gesture... and a reflection on history in a way that seems so absent today with our leadership.  I also think we need to focus on the road ahead and creating opportunities and promoting equality there.  I suppose that's where gestures become more than just gestures.

    on another tip, good to see a kureishi enthusiast on here, I love the Buddha of Suburbia and Black Album, I have Intimacy, but haven't read it.

    I groot about getting past all the bull-doody.
  •  02-28-2007, 7:12 AM 158 in reply to 144

    Re: Should New York Apologize for Slavery?

    I think an apology of this magnitude seems more apprporiate coming from the state, but from "the capital of the world", such an acknoweldgement would be from our lips to the globe's ears.

    And like the previous grooter said, recognizing one's mistakes is central to healing/moving on. What are we so afraid of? It's no secret slavery was some bulls#1@! By putting it out in the open, we can start building for real.

    A friend of mine said to me recently that the U.S. isn't ready for a Black president. His point was that we are in fact, the same nation that eleceted Bush even after he stole the first election. If we ever hope to become a country rooted in equality, it's going to take some sincere effort and meaningful action!


    get your groot on
  •  04-06-2007, 4:54 PM 271 in reply to 158

    Re: Should New York Apologize for Slavery?

    This is a really interesting topic.  What are the states afraid of?  Attribution?

     I always believed in leading by action and the US and its union members can't get there act together but DC is still trying to be a global leader ...   no wonder we're losing credibility.  We must lead by our actions, not our words.

     

  •  04-12-2007, 6:57 AM 288 in reply to 144

    Re: Should New York Apologize for Slavery?

    There was an interesting op-ed in WSJ about this topic earlier this week.  The writer seems to feel that this type of apologies are merely symbolic and a waste of time, arguing that they take too much of the govt's time.

     Resolutions are symbolic but vital in acknowledging flaws of society and in raising awareness of social issues.  I think this is great step and I'm glad NYC Council Members are stepping up:

    *************************************************
    COUNCIL MEMBERS TO INTRODUCE LEGISLATION APOLOGIZING FOR SLAVERY
    *************************************************
    CITY HALL, NY – Elected officials today announced legislation, to be
    introduced in the City Council, which acknowledges New York City's
    historic role in sustaining the slave trade as well as benefiting from
    the forced labor of African slaves.  The City Council resolution,
    sponsored by Council Members John C. Liu, Larry B. Seabrook, and
    Robert Jackson, expresses "profound regret for slavery and historic
    wrongs rooted in racial and cultural bias."

    CM Seabrook, Chairperson of the Civil Rights Committee, stated: "There
    cannot be peace without justice.  And, there cannot be justice without
    truth.  The truth is New York City benefited enormously from the
    brutal slave system that built our economy and our country.  Until we
    recognize and hold ourselves accountable to this truth, we cannot
    achieve the peace and reconciliation that will help move us forward as
    a strong and unified nation."

    CM Jackson, Co-Chair of the Black, Latino, Asian Caucus, stated: "Our
    school system must do a better job of educating our children about the
    history of our own city.  We hope this resolution will spur dialogue
    and interest amongst the new generation of New Yorkers who will lead
    us in the future."

    CM Liu stated: "New York is the greatest city in the world.  But let's
    face it – the early foundation of this city was built on the backs of
    slaves.  Today we are a civilized and progressive society that
    embraces diversity.  As such, it is right to acknowledge a wrongful
    past.  An apology will create deeper understanding and bring people
    together."

    Text of the draft resolution is attached below.

    ---

    Res. No. ___

    Resolution expressing profound regret for slavery and historic wrongs
    rooted in racial and cultural bias.

    By Council Members Liu, Seabrook, and Jackson

    Whereas, The founders of the United States of America, proclaiming the
    nation's sovereignty in 1776, declared, "We hold these truths to be
    self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by
    their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are
    Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness;" and

    Whereas, Racial and cultural bias, afflictions of human civilization
    since its very genesis, were already deeply rooted in American, and
    New York's, culture at the time of the country's independence, for
    example, in the instance of the Dutch West India Company's first cargo
    delivery of eleven African slaves to New Netherland in 1626; and

    Whereas, Perhaps the rawest and most egregious example of racial bias
    is the institution of human slavery, in which a fundamental denial of
    equality and human rights permits the assignment of the bestial
    statuses of 'commodity' and 'chattel' to entire groups of people
    based, among many possible and equivalently illegitimate
    considerations, on the color of their skin, the tenets of their
    religion, or the contempt of their sex; and

    Whereas, Slave labor in New Netherland played a crucial role in
    building the infrastructure for a New World civilization, clearing
    forests, laying roads, raising homes and public buildings, and growing
    food; indeed, in reference to New Netherland's struggle to establish
    agricultural self-sufficiency, Edgar McManus notes in "A History of
    Negro Slavery in New York," "Slavery helped to prepare the way for
    this transition by providing the labor which made farming attractive
    and profitable to settlers. Slave labor was especially important in
    the agricultural development of the Hudson Valley, where an acute
    scarcity of free workers prevailed;" and

    Whereas, During the colonial period, slaves considered to be
    dependable and to have demonstrated reliable service might be offered
    a perverse half-freedom in exchange for regular tribute to the Dutch
    West India Company and compulsion to labor on specific company
    projects, a fiscally-driven part-time forced labor practice utilized
    even by Peter Stuyvesant; and

    Whereas, British rule of New York resulted in even greater growth of
    the slave trade, transforming the local slavery paradigm from one
    based on forced labor for project purposes to a marketplace in human
    misery focused more specifically on the business of selling human
    lives; and

    Whereas, Those slaves who might seek escape and freedom from bondage,
    through organized revolt or individual flight, were subjected to the
    cruelest tortures imaginable: burned alive, lynched, dismembered –
    living beings deemed less than human and subjected to most unnatural
    and inhuman treatments by a society anesthetized to its own humanity
    by the scourge of slavery; and

    Whereas, New York's abolition of slavery was a gradual, slow process,
    described by Northwestern University Professor David Gellman as
    "political give and take, though it seems appalling that real human
    beings should be subject to this give and take," and in the face of
    the specter of eventual abolition, slave owners hurried to sell their
    slaves – and any other blacks they might be able to capture - in
    Southern markets; scholar Edgar McManus notes in "A History of Negro
    Slavery in New York" that after 1800, the New York's black population
    growth rate stagnated as "the exodus was largely the work of
    kidnappers and illegal traders who dealt in human misery;" and

    Whereas, Gradual abolition created categories and subcategories of
    slavery; for example, a 1799 state act freed all children born to New
    York slaves after July 4, 1799, but nevertheless required these
    children to serve their mothers' masters until males reached the age
    of 28 and females reached the age of 25; indeed, these carefully
    distinguished gradations of slavery and servitude amount to little
    more than semantics of degradation; and

    Whereas, According to historian Leslie Harris's "In the Shadow of
    Slavery: African Americans in New York City, 1626-1863," following the
    January 1863 enactment of the Emancipation Proclamation, "Democratic
    Party leaders raised the specter of a New York deluged with southern
    blacks," a flood which would supposedly create overwhelming labor
    competition that would completely upset and ruin the antediluvian
    City's economy; and

    Whereas, An outgrowth of such rumor mongering as well as simmering
    racial, political, and financial tensions, the New York City Draft
    Riots of 1863 revealed a City torn apart by bias and hatred, during
    which eleven black men were lynched, countless blacks were beaten,
    hundreds of blacks were forced out of New York City, and property,
    including homes, stores, and orphanages, and public buildings, was
    burned and destroyed; and

    Whereas, Slavery is not the only stain on New York's past, and denial
    of fundamental rights and oppression have extended to groups other
    than Africans; and

    Whereas, Racial and cultural bias may be said to characterize the
    American nation's relationship with North American indigenous peoples
    including the New York Iroquoian tribes – St. Regis Mohawk, Oneida,
    Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca Nation, Tonawanda Band of Seneca, and
    Tuscorora; the Shinnecock tribe; and the Poospatuck tribe –
    once-independent nations subjected without due process to
    dispossession of their land and consigned to reservations with little
    comprehension of or regard to ties to land or family; and

    Whereas, In not establishing universal suffrage to women until
    ratification of the 19th Amendment to the Constitution in 1920,
    America lagged behind nations like New Zealand, Finland, Norway, and
    Denmark, and within the United States itself, states like Wyoming,
    Colorado, Utah, and Illinois preceded New York in granting suffrage;
    in this regard, cultural biases delayed the political equality of
    women due to now-incomprehensible assumptions about the roles and
    abilities of the female sex and

    Whereas, Women in New York were extended the right to vote in 1917, an
    accomplishment due in great part to decades of both local and national
    organizing led by renowned New York activists like Elizabeth Cady
    Stanton, an organizer of the landmark 1848 Seneca Falls Convention,
    and suffragist and temperance advocate Susan B. Anthony; and

    Whereas, More than three centuries after the year 1776 and nearing the
    150 year anniversary of the Civil War, the estimable promise of the
    words of the Declaration of Independence remains unfulfilled, and the
    inaccessibility of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness which
    many of our fellow New Yorkers experience is manifest in the myriad
    forms of oppression and inequity still borne of racial and cultural
    bias; and

    Whereas, African American, Hispanic-American, Asian American and
    Native American communities continue to suffer from financial and
    social inequities, patterns of housing segregation, deficiencies in
    educational resources, and de facto remnants of formerly codified
    racism; and

    Whereas, Cultural misunderstandings and subjection to bias are the
    unlucky legacy of any group that may differ from the status quo, and,
    today, immigrant communities, persons with disabilities, and the
    ***, gay, bixexual, and transgender community are just a few
    examples of additional groups facing constant threat of bias from
    other citizens in addition to legal requirements and exclusions often
    decried as unfair, inequitable, and inconsiderate of these groups'
    civil and human rights; and

    Whereas, In considering the value and necessity of an expression of
    regret and, in essence, an apology, the Council of the City of New
    York recognizes that reconciliation and healing of historical wounds
    inflicted by racial and cultural bias is possible only with the
    extension of a formal recognition of injurious actions and formal
    repentance for both those actions and their persistent repercussions;
    and

    Whereas, As one of the world's most diverse cities, truly
    representative in makeup of the professed American ideal of a societal
    melting pot, New York City acknowledges with great pride the strides
    it has taken, legislatively, socially, and otherwise, in promoting a
    more just, more humane, more equal society, driven not by racial and
    cultural bias but by a firm commitment to a belief that there is
    strength in diversity, power in understanding, and that, without
    qualification, all men are created equal, now, therefore, be it

    Resolved, That the Council of the City of New York expresses profound
    regret for slavery and historic wrongs rooted in racial and cultural
    bias.

    Filed under: ,
  •  04-13-2007, 4:40 PM 293 in reply to 288

    Re: Should New York Apologize for Slavery?

    did the US federal govt apologize for slavery?  If not, this city-to-city and state-to-state resolutions definitely feels "grooted", ground up, and empowering.



    effecting change one relation at a time.
    Filed under:
  •  04-22-2007, 2:11 PM 311 in reply to 144

    Re: Should New York Apologize for Slavery?

    *************************************************

    CITY COUNCIL TO INTRODUCE LEGISLATION APOLOGIZING FOR NYC ROLE IN SLAVERY

    *************************************************

    CITY HALL, NY – Elected officials and community leaders will announce

    the introduction of City Council legislation "expressing profound

    regret for slavery and historic wrongs rooted in racial and cultural

    bias."  The resolution, sponsored by Council Members John C. Liu,

    Larry B. Seabrook (Chairperson of the Civil Rights Committee) and

    Robert Jackson, (Co-Chair of the Black, Latino, and Asian Caucus),

    acknowledges New York City's role in sustaining and benefiting from

    the slave trade.  *[Text of draft resolution is attached below].

     

    WHAT:

    Council Members to Introduce Legislation Expressing Profound Regret

    for Slavery and Historic Wrongs Rooted in Racial & Cultural Bias.

     

    WHEN:

    Monday, April 23, 2007 at 1:00 PM.

     

    WHERE:

    City Hall, Steps.

     

    WHO:

    Council Members JOHN LIU, LARRY SEABROOK, ROBERT JACKSON.

    Rev. NICHOLAS GENEVIEVE-TWEED, Macedonia A.M.E. Church.

    National Association for the Advancement of Colored Peoples (NY).

    SONIA OSSORIO, President of National Organization of Women (NYC).

    LAKSHMJI ANANTNARAYAN, Communications Director, Equality Now!

    JASON HANDLEY, American Civil Rights Education Services, Inc.

    CARL CALLENDAR, Executive Director, Queens Legal Services.

    JOHN PARK, President, Korean American Community Empowerment Council.

    VICKI SHU SMOLIN, President, Organization of Chinese Americans (NY)

    WONKYUNG JESSICA LEE, Executive Director, Korean American League for

    Civic Action.

     

    - text of draft resolution -

     

    Res. No.___

     

    Resolution expressing profound regret for slavery and historic wrongs

    rooted in racial and cultural bias.

     

    By Council Members Liu, Seabrook, and Jackson

     

    Whereas, The founders of the United States of America, proclaiming the

    nation's sovereignty in 1776, declared, "We hold these truths to be

    self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by

    their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are

    Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness;" and

     

    Whereas, Racial and cultural bias, afflictions of human civilization

    since its very genesis, were already deeply rooted in American, and

    New York's, culture at the time of the country's independence, for

    example, in the instance of the Dutch West India Company's first cargo

    delivery of eleven Africans to New Netherland in 1626; and

     

    Whereas, Perhaps the most rawest and most egregious example of racial

    bias is the institution of human slavery, in which a fundamental

    denial of equality and human rights permits the assignment of the

    bestial statuses of 'commodity' and 'chattel' to entire groups of

    people based, among many possible and equivalently illegitimate

    considerations, on the color of their skin, the tenets of their

    religion, or the contempt of their sex; and

     

    Whereas, Slave labor in New Netherland played a crucial role in

    building the infrastructure for a New World civilization, clearing

    forests, laying roads, raising homes and public buildings, and growing

    food; indeed, in reference to New Netherlands' struggle to establish

    agricultural self-sufficiency, Edgar McManus notes in "A History of

    Negro Slavery in New York," "Slavery helped to prepare the way for

    this transition by providing the labor which made farming attractive

    and profitable to settlers.  Slave labor was especially important in

    the agricultural development of the Hudson Valley, where an acute

    scarcity of free workers prevailed;" and

     

    Whereas, During the colonial period, slaves considered to be

    dependable and to have demonstrated reliable service might be offered

    a perverse half-freedom in exchange for regular tribute to the Dutch

    West India Company and compulsion to labor on specific company

    projects, a fiscally-driven part-time forced labor practice utilized

    even by Peter Stuyvesant; and

     

    Whereas, British rule of New York resulted in even greater growth of

    the slave trade, transforming the local slavery paradigm from one

    based on forced labor for project purposes to a marketplace in human

    misery focused more specifically on the business of selling human

    lives; and

     

    Whereas, Those slaves who might seek escape and freedom from bondage,

    through organized revolt or individual flight, were subjected to the

    cruelest tortures imaginable: burned alive, lynched, dismembered –

    living beings deemed less than human and subjected to most unnatural

    and inhuman treatments by a society anesthetized to its own humanity

    by the scourge of slavery; and

     

    Whereas, New York's abolition of slavery was a gradual, slow process,

    described by Northwestern University Professor David Gellman as

    "political give and take, though it seems appalling that real human

    beings should be subject to this give and take," and in the face of

    the specter of eventual abolition, slave owners hurried to sell their

    slaves – and any other blacks they might be able to capture - in

    Southern markets; scholar Edgar McManus notes in "A History of Negro

    Slavery in New York" that after 1800, the New York's black population

    growth rate stagnated as "the exodus was largely the work of

    kidnappers and illegal traders who dealt in human misery;" and

     

    Whereas, Gradual abolition created categories and subcategories of

    slavery; for example, a 1799 state act freed all children born to New

    York slaves after July 4, 1799, but nevertheless required these

    children to serve their mothers' masters until males reached the age

    of 28 and females reached the age of 25; indeed, these carefully

    distinguished gradations of slavery and servitude amount to little

    more than semantics of degradation; and

     

    Whereas, According to historian Leslie Harris's "In the Shadow of

    Slavery: African Americans in New York City, 1626-1863," following the

    January 1863 enactment of the Emancipation Proclamation, "Democratic

    Party leaders raised the specter of a New York deluged with southern

    blacks," a flood which would supposedly create overwhelming labor

    competition that would completely upset and ruin the antediluvian

    City's economy; and

     

    Whereas, An outgrowth of such rumor mongering as well as simmering

    racial, political, and financial tensions, the New York City Draft

    Riots of 1863 revealed a City torn apart by bias and hatred, during

    which eleven black men were lynched, countless blacks were beaten,

    hundreds of blacks were forced out of New York City, and property,

    including homes, stores, and orphanages, and public buildings, was

    burned and destroyed; and

     

    Whereas, Slavery is not the only stain on New York's past, and denial

    of fundamental rights and oppression have extended to groups other

    than Africans; and

     

    Whereas, Racial and cultural bias may be said to characterize the

    American nation's relationship with North American indigenous peoples

    including the New York Iroquoian tribes – St. Regis Mohawk, Oneida,

    Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca Nation, Tonawanda Band of Seneca, and

    Tuscorora; the Shinnecock tribe; and the Poospatuck tribe,

    once-independent nations subjected without due process to

    dispossession of their land and consigned to reservations with little

    comprehension of or regard to ties to land or family; and

     

    Whereas, In not establishing universal suffrage to women until

    ratification of the 19th Amendment to the Constitution in 1920,

    America lagged behind nations like New Zealand, Finland, Norway, and

    Denmark, and within the United States itself, states like Wyoming,

    Colorado, Utah, and Illinois preceded New York in granting suffrage;

    in this regard, cultural biases delayed the political equality of

    women due to now-incomprehensible assumptions about the roles and

    abilities of the female sex and

     

    Whereas, Women in New York were extended the right to vote in 1917, an

    accomplishment due in great part to decades of both local and national

    organizing led by renowned New York activists like Elizabeth Cady

    Stanton, an organizer of the landmark 1848 Seneca Falls Convention,

    and suffragist and temperance advocate Susan B. Anthony; and

     

    Whereas, More than three centuries after the year 1776 and nearing the

    150 year anniversary of the Civil War, the estimable promise of the

    words of the Declaration of Independence remains unfulfilled, and the

    inaccessibility of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness which

    many of our fellow New Yorkers experience is manifest in the myriad

    forms of oppression and inequity still borne of racial and cultural

    bias; and

     

    Whereas, African American, Hispanic-American,  Asian American and

    Native American communities continue to suffer from financial and

    social inequities, patterns of housing segregation, deficiencies in

    educational resources, and de facto remnants of formerly codified

    racism; and

     

    Whereas, Cultural misunderstandings and subjection to bias are the

    unlucky legacy of any group that may differ from the status quo, and,

    today, immigrant communities, persons with disabilities, and the

    ***, gay, bisexual, and transgender community are just a few

    examples of additional groups facing constant threat of bias from

    other citizens in addition to legal requirements and exclusions often

    decried as unfair, inequitable, and inconsiderate of these groups'

    civil and human rights; and

     

    Whereas, In considering the value and necessity of an expression of

    regret and, in essence, an apology, the Council of the City of New

    York recognizes that reconciliation and healing of historical wounds

    inflicted by racial and cultural bias is possible only with the

    extension of a formal recognition of injurious actions and formal

    repentance for both those actions and their persistent repercussions;

    and

     

    Whereas, As one of the world's most diverse cities, truly

    representative in makeup of the professed American ideal of a societal

    melting pot, New York City acknowledges with great pride the strides

    it has taken, legislatively, socially, and otherwise, in promoting a

    more just, more humane, more equal society, driven not by racial and

    cultural bias but by a firm commitment to a belief that there is

    strength in diversity, power in understanding, and that, without

    qualification, all men are created equal, now, therefore, be it